How we rate

The score

Albums and bands get a score out of 10. It is one listener's verdict on how well the record holds up today, not a measure of sales or chart success.

Track calls

  • Essential: the songs to hear first.
  • Good: worth your time once you know the album.
  • Skippable: fine to pass on.

Band tiers

  • Platinum: a run of hit records.
  • One big hit: remembered for one song or one album.
  • Cult favorite: never broke big, still worth hearing.

What doesn't change a score

Affiliate links never affect a rating. Records are rated the same way whether or not a store sells them.